Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Overcoming Bias Commenter's avatar

I detect a lot of emotional rather than logical responses in this comment thread.

Expand full comment
Overcoming Bias Commenter's avatar

J, is there any reason to talk to Graham? When we were funding SDI under Reagan, the actual scientists and engineers said it wouldn't work. The money quote I got from Larry ****** at SAIC, "It can't work, but now my retirement is assured." But the top SDI guys said we had to spend the money anyway, that we couldn't prove it wouldn't work.

So later they said even though it wouldn't work, still there was a possibility it would work against an attack from china, who only had 15 missiles and warheads. But pretty soon china had 250 nukes and it wouldn't work against china either.

So now here's the same guy, claiming that one single missile from iran could destroy the nation, and SDI can shoot down that missile. He has a solution that's looking for a problem. He's been lying about it for 20+ years.

Why would you pay attention to him this time around?

If you want information about this potential problem, why get it from somebody who's been lying about it for a long time? "Fool me once...."

Expand full comment
54 more comments...