Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Overcoming Bias Commenter's avatar

I agree with your thesis, but this particular argument seems to be equally explained by poor accounting - all your examples talk about situations where power is easily and quickly gauged, while adjusting for handicap requires time and conscious attention.

Do you have an instance where inferring power is hard, handicap easy and automatic, yet people still seem to emphasize the former?

Otherwise it's just the usual - What's Quickly Processed Is All There Is.

Expand full comment
Dave Lindbergh's avatar

I want my intellectual intellectual heroes to be prestigious and competent. Not dominant. (Do you think I'm mistaken about this?)

When awarding prizes, just as when awarding business to a seller, we want to reward achievement. Whether the person faced obstacles to that achievement is not my problem as a buyer - I just want maximum value for my money.

Same for prizes. I want to reward people who achieve great things, and to encourage others to do the same. Whether it was easy or hard for them to do this is their problem, not mine.

The real world doesn't grade on effort.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...